Persephone Nicholls believes she's living a real live Cinderella story when she's swept off her feet by the handsome and wealthy, Garrett Byrne, but when Byrne begins to show his darker side, Reverend Patrick O'Connor offers friendship, warmth, and maybe even love. The problem is, with their wavy auburn hair, solid bodies, and deep blue machine gun eyes, the two men look so much alike that Percy can't seem to keep her emotions straight. Will these heavenly feelings cast her straight into hell?