Sally Holmes and her trusty sidekick Sherlock are solving their strangest case yet. When a trip to the grocery store leads to her finding a pair of hands hidden in a fruit bin, Sally knows she has to find out where they came from. She goes on a wild goose chase to try to find clues, and ends up stumbling on a completely different mystery along the way. Can a feud between two local theaters have anything to do with the creepy hands? Sally's determined to find out. Join her and her friends as she explores a farm, investigates an actress, and sleuths her way to the culprit, one grisly clue at a time.