As a self-employed electrician, Lloyd Barrett doesn't meet a lot of eligible gay men on the job. So he downloads a dating app on a whim, and is surprised to find a profile for Doug Pfost, the former quarterback of his high school football team. He's even more surprised when Doug likes his photo. Soon they meet up at a local bar after work. Doug tells Lloyd he married his high school sweetheart after graduation but now, ten years and a young son later, Doug is in the process of getting a divorce and looking to explore his sexuality. Even though they seem to hit it off, Doug runs out on him when Lloyd gets up to pay the bill. Later that evening, Doug calls to ask for a second chance. However, this second date also results in Doug bailing. Doug begs for patience as he struggles to come out. Is Lloyd willing to give Doug another second chance?