Mark Louis and Kristy King visit Erin Blakely, a college friend of Kristy's whom she hasn't seen in half-a-dozen years. During their visit, Jeremy Casterbridge, an old college boyfriend of Erin's, shows up, claiming to be the father of Erin's daughter, Raven. When a murder occurs, Mark, Kristy, Erin, and Jeremy are swept up in the aftermath. Hoping to uncover the truth about Erin's tangled life, Mark and Kristy set out to investigate the men in Erin's past and present. They find that love really does conquer all—or at least tries its best to.