Twenty-six year old Honey Pieretti is sick and tired of being so nice. After her helpfulness leads to humiliation on her favorite baking-themed TV show, she and her lifelong best friend, Carter, decide to cast aside their trusting personalities by starting a competition to toughen up.

It's all fun and games until Honey realizes she's falling in love with her best friend. Convinced he doesn't feel the same way, she must decide if she can live without his friendship or hide her feelings forever. But as the competition heats up and Honey's given a chance at TV redemption, she finds that more than just love could ruin their friendship.

Can she prove to the boy next door that she's still the girl he knows?