It's Christmastime in Foxglove Corners where danger mixes with holiday cheer. A skater who fell through the ice fifty years ago returns to haunt the lake where she died. Meanwhile, a woman trips over a reindeer dog toy left on a step and falls to her death. Her friend spreads a rumor that the collie, Gemini, plotted her owner's death.

As Jennet Ferguson attempts to create the perfect Christmas for her husband, Crane, and to plan a family wedding, she must champion Gemini, discover the identity of a killer, and figure out the significance of the phantom skater apparition.