Ellis Collins doesn't mind his parents arranging a blind date for him. When they insist the date should take place at the restaurant they own, Ellis agrees. Everything would have been okay if he hadn't identified the wrong man as his blind date. He's beyond mortified, especially when his real blind date arrives. Braylon Larsen is initially annoyed because Ellis has mistaken another man for him, but when he discovers the stranger is Drew Vinson, one of his favorite authors, he quickly calms down. The three of them enjoy themselves. They even start hanging out together. Drew is attracted to both Ellis and Braylon. It's obvious Braylon is also interested in Ellis and Drew. Ellis doesn't seem to reciprocate their feelings, but Drew isn't sure because the man is a lot harder to figure out. Will the three men find their happily ever after in the end?