(Formerly published as The Big Beautiful Amish Woman).
Mary has been getting along wonderfully with Caleb. After he hears her talking about marrying him, he tells her it can never be. Mary wonders if something in Caleb's past is holding him back, and she's shocked when her friend suggests it's got something to do with her looks. She had never thought she was any different from any other woman, but could it be true? Is she so unloveable the way she is? Will Mary's hopes of finding true love always elude her?