With her older sister married and her mamm determined she'll be next, Tulip Yoder agrees to court the one Amish man who doesn't have her mother's approval. But when she meets Wilhem Byler, who she can't help but feel drawn to, she's not sure what to do.

With two potential suitors, she must make a decision and turn one away. Though her heart tells her Wilhem might be exactly the man she's been looking for, choosing him means she'll have to tell him the truth. And once he discovers he wasn't her first choice, will she be able to convince him he's the only man she wants to marry?