When a mugger steals more than her boyfriend's wallet, Finley's life is turned upside-down.
Finley had only just learned her boyfriend, Rory, was a twin. An incident in their home the night before left more than rivalry between the two brothers; Rory was out for revenge. Before he can rightfully deal with Randy, they are mugged and one of them killed.
Upon her arrival at the hospital, Finley is horrified to learn they are unsure which one lived. After almost a year with the man she's loved like no other, she has no problem figuring out it's Rory. Elation immediately replaces her worst fear. Days pass, the incident forgotten, life goes on, only much better. Rory is far more attentive and loving and finally proposes. Finley has never been happier.
One by one, secrets are revealed about Rory's past, and Finley discovers the last year of her life has been a complete lie. Although she's unable to know what to do about staying with the man she thought she loved, two reasons make her feelings impossible to deny him.