Eli and Johnny shared their first kiss at a camp for the hearing impaired. Eli even gets Johnny to speak the word, kiss. They go their separate ways, but fate brings them back together on Valentine's Day twenty years later, where happily ever after begins. Or does it? For much of the time between summer camp and Valentine's Day, it was Eli and Casey, the best friend with benefits. Casey thinks things might be moving too fast for Eli and Johnny. Plus, the relationship has bumps from the start. Johnny's family responsibilities mean his time with Eli is limited to the point of frustration. Suddenly happily ever after doesn't feel as certain. Is Johnny and Eli's reunion just a moment, not a lifetime? Is there room in Eli's life for Casey still? And then there's Eddie ...