A forbidden love. A family torn. And a secret that could alter life as they know it.

Ever since Shiloh Miller was paired up with handsome Mikey Eicher at her best friend's wedding, she's been head-over-heels for him. But Mikey has a penchant for trouble. Just like his father, according to Dat. Which is why she's been forbidden to date him. But in spite of Dat's insistence, her heart has other plans.

Mikey wants Shiloh in his life more than anything, but his soul yearns for the Englisch world. He chalks up his desires to being born and adopted outside the Amish when in his tender years. Between Silas's view on his and Shiloh's relationship, and the quarrel with his grossdawdi Sammy, Mikey is more than ready to leave his Amish community and try out a different life.

All is going as planned until his life is turned upside down and he learns a secret that will rock everyone's world. Will he lose those he loves the most when the walls cave in around him?