The only thing Kara has ever wanted for Christmas was a pony. Every year, her list was the same – one pony (pretty please with sprinkles on top?). Every year, she got pajamas and plastic horse models, but no pony. Her hopes were high when she and her mother moved out to her grandparents' old farm. But instead of ponies, she found a spoiled fairy princess!

When she reluctantly agrees to search for the fairy's missing sugar bowl, she discovers a whole society of fairies, gnomes, and woodland creatures. With magic everywhere, will Kara finally get her wish?