Sidney's matchmaking business is suffering. When her best friend convinces her to put on a fake engagement ring to boost customer confidence in her, she reluctantly agrees. Couldn't hurt to try, right? And when her childhood crush comes walking in, she's glad to have her fake engagement as an excuse not to get involved with him. He shattered her heart ten years ago, and she can't take another painful Blake incident.
Blake can't believe it when he sees Sidney, all grown up. She looks amazing. But she's also off limits, or so he thinks. When he finds out she's not really engaged, he's confused as to why Sidney would lie to him. He makes it his goal to coax the truth out of her, even if he has to go to great lengths to do it.