Becca — a Halloween-hating, awkward twenty-four-year-old — is once again dreading the approach of fall when she's told that her best friend's sister, Amy, is back in town. Amy is charismatic, smart, and successful, and Becca has been nursing feelings for her since high school, when they were on opposite ends of the social spectrum. Now that Amy's come out as a lesbian, though, she's theoretically within shot — if only Becca can muster up the courage. Unbeknownst to Becca, her best friend has already let Amy know she's single. When Amy texts her, hoping to reconnect, Becca jumps at the chance to go to the local cafe with her. It's not a date, she tells herself, but part of her suspects it is. What follows is hours of reminiscing as they each bring up things the other has forgotten, or never knew in the first place. Will Becca be able to overcome her insecurity and follow up on her suspicions? Or will she let the opportunity slip through her fingers again?