Avery Quinn never dated much in high school, so her friends challenged her to find a boyfriend by the start of her senior year. She failed. To save face, Avery creates a boyfriend, Garrett Cross, on Facebook. Her friends are satisfied, and all of the fuss about a boyfriend dies down - until she finds out that her imaginary boyfriend is real and moving to her hometown! Life becomes even more complicated when her best friend, Jace Michaels, confesses his love for her, and she finds herself in a downward spiral of lies, intrigue, and heartbreak.