Rachel is an Amish woman who is on a quest for independence, having been raised in a super strict household and with little love. Inspired by a woman in town who spoke of her adventures on her Rumspringa, Rachel leaves to take a job in the next town over and falls for the charms of a very attractive man. Although he does have a chip on his shoulder, she tries to change him with her kindness. But she has another suitor in an Amish man who has had a crush on her since forever. Can he return her to the Amish community so they can start a family?