Rebekah has been deeply in love with Jacob since as far as she could remember. But someone is stealing from her parent's farm in her Amish community. One day it is a chicken. The next day a cow. The thefts then extend to the farms around the town and Rebekah starts to do her own investigation. To her dismay, she starts to suspect that Jacob may be involved in a burglary ring in her town and the next one over. Why is Jacob doing this? Does she really know his character and if she finds out the truth, will it break her heart beyond repair?