Annie is an Amish girl that likes to do things her way...she's always been a little stand-offish in the community and has a quirky sense of humor that no one seems to get. She spends a lot of time alone and sometimes eats too much to comfort her loneliness. Her sister, Eve, is the opposite...popular among the boys because of her beauty, everyone who meets her cannot help but compliment her on how pretty she is. Now Eve has a new suitor, Steven, who is a bit socially awkward like Annie. The three go out together and Steven and Annie have more to say to one another than Eve who is starting to lose interest in Steven altogether. Can Steven look past appearances and see that maybe he and Annie are met to be together? Can Annie break out of her shell and see that she is right for Steven?