Sarah was content with her life. Jonah was the perfect suitor for her; he was kind, compassionate and humble. He was the one who healed her broken heart and made her realize there were second chances in love. But when Caleb Yoder arrives back in town after being away on an extended Rumspringa everything is turned upside down.
Confused by the sudden turmoil and conflicting emotions, Sarah tries to figure out the matters of her heart. Caleb had been her first love, but he deserted her. And through the years, she secretly held on to the letters Caleb had written her before he had left. Lying not only to herself but to Jonah and pretending she was over him.
Now with the truth staring her straight in the face, she has do decide between Caleb and Jonah...