Matthew Miller wanted to make it work in the big city, but even with his determination and passion to live a modern life, nothing could prepare him for the day he had to face the music. With his tail between his legs, he had no choice but to return to his home. But fitting in with the Amish way of life, wasn't as much a challenge as coming to terms with the fact that he still had feelings for the once shy Amelia Hartsberger.
Amelia was once bitten twice shy; she couldn't allow her heart to be broken again. She had a crush on Matthew when they were young, but he hardly paid any attention to her, now, years later, he shows up and suddenly he can't leave her alone. Fighting against the whirl of emotions, she tries to avoid the inevitable. But Matthew is determined, and in all honesty, a changed man, who she finds hard to resist. And they have one important thing in common : "Socks".