Rebecca is a shy Amish spinster that everyone tries to play matchmaker for. Her other two sisters are already married and she begins to feel the pressure to find someone by everyone close to her. She is set up with some perfectly eligible men in the community but Rebecca turns them down. Why? Because she secretly has a crush on a handsome young man who visits her bakery every morning. The problem is that he seems even more shy than she is. Can she break out of her shell and break the ice with him?