When Katie dies, Sarah's only goal is to get her four friends back to her Amish town to honor her death. Amazingly, she has stayed alone in the town while her friends went to the Englisch world as soon as they could. Her friends arrive but she soon realizes that the women are tangled in secrets that the Amish town has hidden. Why did all the women leave the town? Sarah works to find out the truth and begins to realize what matters most is faith, family and friendship.