Caroline and Paul have been best friends since grade school. As they've grown older, they never developed a romantic interest in one another until marriage becomes a possibility...with other people. Caroline is being courted by John who secretly wants to have them leave the Amish town and spend their lives in the Englisch world. Paul is courting Rebekah...she's the town beauty and has developed a crush on him. Hearing this, Paul only feels obligated to date Rebekah...but soon realizes that he doesn't want to be separated from Caroline. Does she feel the same way about him?