It is a record breaking winter in the small Amish town...And someone is taking full advantage by breaking into homes.
The thief has done his homework on the residents. He is targeting only the senior residents of the town much to the dismay of the new Sheriff in the county. Wanting to make amends with both the people and his teen sweetheart, Lovina, the Sheriff has a lot on his plate.
The home of Lovina's grandparents is burglarized and she is shellshocked. The thief eludes capture and the whole town is frightened. Lovina works with the Sheriff in his investigation as old romantic feelings become anew. But will this burglar be the obstacle that prevents them from mending the past?