Esther is a young Amish woman hired by a recently widowed man to help take care of his child. Esther agrees to terms with Isaac, but soon grows to love both him and his child. Esther thinks Isaac has feelings for him as well but they are both too shy and professional to make those feelings known. Isaac's family feels the need to help him find another wife so they begin seeking out another mate for him. Esther then begins to fear that their love will be forever unrequited. Or will one of them finally admit their feelings before it is too late?