Rachel is a young Amish woman undecided on what she wants out of life. Her father expects her to remain in the community and find a husband. But her best friend Lovina left the Amish town and now seems happier than anyone she knows.
Her confusion extends to her romantic life as well as she finds Abraham to be somewhat boring and predictable while the Englisch David is his polar opposite in every way. But is she truly seeing the Amish life and Abraham for what they are?