Rachel is a midwife with a broken heart. The man she loved left her Amish community years ago and she spends her days caring for the women of her faith. She has all but given up hope for marriage and children while aiding those who she feels are blessed enough to have those things. But when the man who had broken her heart returns to the community during Christmas season, she can't help but feel a tinge of hope. He said he has changed and wants to repent. But is he sincere? And will Rachel risk her heart again?