The orphaned Henry couldn't wait to leave for his Rumspringa as soon as he was old enough. But he had pleasant memories of the times he spent in the Amish community and has eyes for Sarah. Henry returns home and his boasts of being scouted by a major league baseball team thrill almost all the Amish community except Sarah, who doubts his story. When it turns out the story is real, Hobie asks the family-oriented Sarah to marry him but to leave the Amish community and join him in the Englisch world where he will pursue fame and glory in his baseball career. Will she join him?