Sarah has been in love with a visiting Englischer named Aden ever since she saw him in church over a year ago. Problem is that her best friend Martha has told her that she has an unrequited crush on him as well. When Aden starts to pursue her, Sarah finds herself in a quandary. Should she return the interest of the young man who seems so kind and thoughtful or does she spurn his advances in order to spare the feelings of her friend?