An Amish anthology headlined by "Cross My Amish Heart"...Hannah Miller works at Miller's Goods, her father's general store which is the place to be in the Amish town. To handle their growing business, her father hires Michael, a handsome young man that immediately catches Hannah's eye. He's a troubled soul, however, with a guilt ridden past which involves the death of his fiancee. He believes he will never feel the same connection he did with fiancee and has sworn off love for good. Through Hannah, will Michael realize that he has only been inflicting more pain on himself by refusing to forgive himself for his girlfriend's death?