When one of Hannibal's Handlers rogues the son of the local Brotherhood, the High Council upgrades the Paladin's orders from recover to reclaim. Mark and Gabriel are both devastated by this news but are sworn to uphold the Brethren Codes of Conduct. Hannibal kidnaps the daughter of the owner of a Goth club and demands a ransom of willing victims. Jes, Michael, and the teams struggle to contain the rogues and recover those that have been taken while facing their own challenges as newlyweds.