Natalie Brannigan should be thrilled to move to a historic sea captain's home on Night Meadow Island with her parents. The mansion has a killer view of the rocky coast and is just down the road from the Knight family, who are so entwined with the Brannigans they might as well be joined at the hip. But while everyone sees beauty and love in the home, Natalie knows there's a dark secret hidden deep within the plaster walls. One that only she can see. And when Jonathan Desjardins, a captivating spirit, appears to her, nobody believes her story. The rest of the witches in her circle think she's living in a fantasy world, and they are determined to shake her from it. But Natalie refuses to give up the one thing she can't have— Jonathan.