Urban Legends fascinate Carena McBride, but when four women who share this fascination are brutally murdered, state police Corporal Zac Ramsey fears Cara will be number five. Carena McBride's life shatters when her husband is killed in the line of duty. She vows never to entrust her fragile heart to a law enforcement hero again and after five turbulent years alone, lured by the prospect of a new beginning, Carina returns to her hometown. A failed marriage convinced State Police Corporal Zac Ramsey he's not good husband material and a promotion offers a welcome distraction. Zac is determined to put his career first... until he encounters Carena. Despite Zac's marriage phobia and Cara's vow, their lives become entangled. The lady becomes more than a rung on Zac's career ladder, and Carina finds happiness she feared forever lost. While Zac investigates murders, Cara pursues a project documenting weird phenomenon until the corporal discovers four victims of recent brutal murders share Cara's fascination with local Urban Legends. Alarmed Cara's project may trigger a demented killer's fury, more than duty drives Zac as he scrambles to keep Carina alive.