Grace Albright is hoping for a Christmas miracle. Grace, a blind schoolteacher, and her father, the Reverend Bill Albright, are trying to keep the local school and church open in the seaside village of Saint Michaels. But they are running out of time. Since the church bells and the pipe organ have gone silent, attendance has dropped. And now, the bishop is coming on Christmas Eve amidst rumors he may announce the closures.
Grace urges her father to enlist her childhood friend, Sam Carpenter, an expert tuner, to step in to bring the church bells back to life. Her father initially refuses, still blaming him for Grace's blindness, but he finally agrees.
During the tuning process, Sam and Grace solve the mystery of the bells of Saint Michaels, but can they make them ring? Can they save the church and experience a Christmas miracle as Grace and Sam find their feelings for each other have blossomed from friendship to love. ? If only...