Everyone knows that Sebastian Jones is dangerous. Reports of the women he's abused have been circulating for years. But as Ella Sweet gets to know him through her church's young adult group, she begins to wonder how much of what everyone knows is actually true. Is he a nice guy who's fallen victim to the rumor mill or is she just another sucker?

Sebastian knows what everyone knows. He's determined to convince Ella that despite what she's heard, he would never hurt her. Just as he begins to earn her trust, a new rumor surfaces. This one hits Sebastian where he's most vulnerable. He can't deny it without sounding defensive. He can't ignore it without looking like he has something to hide.