Susan Carter has her hands full raising twins and running the Galilee Women's Shelter—she doesn't need darkly handsome pastor Gabriel Dawson complicating her life. But she can't avoid him, not after she opens his eyes to the plight of the battered women in his parish, whose drug-addicted men are connected to the Venezuelan cartel La Mano Oscura and the Diablo crime syndicate. Spending time with Gabriel, when he's her auctioned "date" and again with her daughters, shows Susan both the gentleness and protectiveness of the former marine. And once Susan's daughters decide that they want Gabriel as their new daddy, what else is there for a man of God to do...but become a family man?