When Indie, a shy, 40-something accountant, loses herself after a devastating breakup, she rebuilds her life through charity work. Now, a single phone call is threatening to toss her orderly world back into disarray. Not only does she have to replace another woman in her charity's auction, but she's also becoming the group's president thanks to a succession clause in the bylaws! Curvy Indie doesn't believe she can compete with younger, slimmer bachelorettes or follow in outgoing president Don's footsteps – but will the hunky corporate trainer have her back?

After months of women using his charity meetings to look for dates, organization president Don has resorted to screening newcomers. To his delight, one of the few to pass his test is the soft-spoken Indie, who as a CPA quickly proves herself indispensable to the group. Four years later, she is a trusted member of his executive board. A surprise resignation puts her next in line for the presidency, as well as a last-minute entry in the charity's date auction.

Can Don overcome Indie's misgivings and help her step out of her comfort zone? Will Indie accept the reins of leadership – and Don's heart? Can these longtime colleagues make a personal connection?