Allison McDonald has a thriving massage practice and a spot on the local roller derby team. When an amazing woman swipes right on her dating profile, life couldn't be more perfect. Perfection turns out to be illusion when she finds out she's been catfished by someone using the photo of the actress, Geena. Determined to protect others from heartbreak, she contacts the dating site and Geena about the fraud.

Virginia Harris's fans know her as "Geena," the lesbian star of a popular web series. Playing the role of Geena, and protecting her identity, is Virginia's latest way of keeping real life—and real love—at arm's length. Until the woman of her dreams walks into her life. But is it Geena she's really interested in?

Their attraction is immediate, but when Allison looks at Virginia, she struggles not to see the woman she thought she was in love with. As the lines between fantasy and reality blur, will they know the real thing?