Tensions rise among the group as Storm revives an old investigation into tales of an Indiana lake monster. Nothing about it makes sense, and it doesn't help that everyone's abilities have been off lately.

The only two who don't seem affected are Storm and the mysterious beauty Julia, who everyone knows but no one seems able to remember anything about.

The mystery only deepens as the group goes back to the lake and encounters angry townsfolk and mysterious messages that weren't there before...