What happens when a professional matchmaker and a pickup artist go head-to-head in a reality TV show?

After a failed marriage, Malcolm Sterling has returned home with plans to take over the family matchmaking business. However, because his mother doubts his ability, he's forced to prove himself by hosting a dating show to help women find love.

The catch? The producers have brought in a pickup artist to act as his co-host, so now it's a competition to determine who is the better matchmaker.

Natalie Hale never intended for her online, dating expert alter ego to provide her with an opportunity of a lifetime. Unfortunately, she's faced with working with a man who is as infuriating as he is tempting. Her secret identity has allowed her to explore dating and relationships, but she needs to keep the two parts of her life separate—which becomes harder the more she works with Malcolm.

Sparks fly as the competition heats up. Malcolm has definitely met his match in Natalie, but when all secrets are exposed, will the ultimate prize be love?