Garrison Ford needs a wife and son before his 35th birthday. He goes to London to find a bride and falls in love with a debutante's elder sister, Sara. Unfortunately, Sara considers herself "ruined and unfit" to be his wife. Desperate to keep the woman he loves in his life, Garrison marries her younger sister, Dana. Returning home with both sisters, Dana, his untouched wife, and Sara, his beloved mistress, Garrison learns that a young lady in town is rumored to be carrying his child. As if this is not tangled enough, Garrison's best friend is determined to free Dana from this tangled knot and take her as his bride.