When Elita's best friend, Carmella, disappears under mysterious circumstances. Elita feels driven to find her. She's convinced the puzzle Carmella was working on the day she disappeared is somehow involved. She takes the puzzle and puts it together herself—and suddenly finds herself pulled into Puzzle Land.

Elita is confronted by a strange and sinister man named Professor Robinson, an evil wizard who cast a spell on puzzles. In the beginning, he wanted to create a special place for the homeless children of the world, but his greed took hold. The professor began to kidnap any child he could.

Soon, Andy and Aaron follow Elita and Carmella into the puzzle. As they travel through Puzzle Land, their bodies begin to take on the shape of a new creature. It is only after they learn to forgive one another, to be honest, and to work as a team that they find the strength to escape Professor Robinson and his puzzle world.