Finn O'Loughlin can't stop thinking about the first woman to ever capture his attention. Not after an unexpected hook up, or even after she mysteriously shows up again on New Year's Eve.

After her sudden reappearance, Finn finds himself in a whirlwind of a relationship. But when the town's most eligible bachelor is suddenly off the market, not everyone is happy about it.

Haunted by the drama of a past hookup, Finn tries to keep his newfound relationship from sinking before it even has the chance to float.

But unbeknownst to him, she's dealing with problems of her own in the form of a sleazy new boss who doesn't take no for an answer.

As their new relationship grows, they realize the secrets they keep just may drive them apart.