Detective Vergil Ross has come to Chance and The Misfits for help in finding his missing brother, private investigator, Horace Ross. Their search for Horace, takes them from their home in Lost Way, PA. to New York City and Lake View, CT. The Misfits decide that Horace's unsolved cases will lead them to the missing man. As they work his cases, they endure horrifying visions, abusive ghosts, a lost teen, a fortune in missing coins, a cheating husband, and an unpleasant past that they thought they had left when they shook Lake View, CT from their heels.

It turns out that finding Horace is just the beginning of this adventure. And just when it looks like a happy ending is ensured for our Misfits, that past returns with a vengeance to threaten their happiness and their very lives.