Andy Parker moves to a small town on a lake to start over after a bad breakup. The big drawback? He's alone with no prospects for romance. He meets Eddie Ferguson at the local grocery and strikes up an easy friendship, but the divorced man isn't really Andy's type. Still, a friend is a friend—and when Mr. Oblivious Eddie says "So use me," Andy's imagination goes wild. But will trying for more risk any chance of a friendship?