Two witchy sisters search for the perfect caretaker. When they find the perfect candidate, they serve him many delicious meals over the next few months. Later, at the winter solstice, the caretaker fulfills his contract and becomes a reluctant participant in the old sisters' celebration.

Apple Pie is the "A" Story in Spooky Shorts, a collection of creepy short stories A-Z: Apple Pie, Black-Eyed Kids, Creature, Dungeon, Electric, Fairy, Genie, House, Ice, Joker, Kiss, Lucid, Minion, Neighbor, Obelisk, Pattern, Quest, Rumor, Squatch, Time, Underworld, Visitor, Wolf, X-axis, Yellow, and ZoZo.