A lot can change in six years. The last time Dylan Scott was in Brogan's Point, he was a nobody. Now he's rich and famous. But he still has memories of the charming seaside New England town where he'd spent one unforgettable night with Gwen Parker, a local shop clerk who'd wanted nothing more than a no-strings-attached fling. Six years later, she's still in town—only now she owns the shop. She's practically engaged to be married. And she's got a five-year-old daughter who looks an awful lot like Dylan.

One thing hasn't changed in Brogan's Point: the antique jukebox in the Faulk Street Tavern. It still plays oldies, and those oldies can still cast spells over the tavern's patrons. When the jukebox plays "Angel of the Morning," a plaintive ballad about love without commitment, Dylan and Gwen realize that walking away from what they'd once had might have been the biggest mistake of their lives. Now, six years later, is it too late to make things right?