After recovering from the unwanted end of a three-year long relationship, Shana Morgan is ready to move on with her life. Her plan to jump back into the dating scene is derailed when her best friend asks her to deliver a "Dear John" message. She reluctantly agrees. Her immediate and powerful attraction to the recipient—a handsome Native American hunk—stuns her. It also leaves her fearing that her inability to resist him will damage her lifelong friendship.

Nine years younger, Taylor Raymond falls hard after viewing a picture of the attractive, full-figured Shana Morgan. Fate smiles on him when she unexpectedly shows up outside his office—to jilt him for her friend. Before he can make the most of his good luck and claim her as his, he'll have to convince her a relationship with him won't be a betrayal of her friend.