Larry's search for love didn't include Greg, his regular waiter at his favorite restaurant. Always too busy daydreaming about a handsome doctor, Larry fails to notice Greg's shy advances. But when Greg finally finds the courage to ask Larry out, he's suddenly killed in a freak car accident. Only then does Larry realize how perfect they could have been together.

No one gets a second shot at true love. Or do they?

Inexplicably, Larry is drawn into a parallel reality, and in this new timeline, Greg is still very much alive. Here, the shy young waiter Larry knew from before has managed to live out many of his dreams. All except one: he hasn't found love. Larry gets one more shot after all!

There are a few problems. One, Larry's time is limited. Two, Greg has already dated the parallel reality's Larry, and he was a real jerk. Now Larry has to prove he's nothing at all like his evil doppelganger and that he is willing to risk everything to protect the man he loves.

He's found Greg again. To keep him, Larry will have to stop daydreaming and fight himself—literally—not just metaphorically.